Job Hound by Lead Dog

Homeowner guide · Handyman services

Handyman vs. contractor: who should you hire?

Hire a handyman for small repairs, installs and odd jobs that don't need a permit, like mounting a TV, patching drywall or swapping a fixture. Hire a licensed contractor or tradesperson for work that needs a permit or license: new wiring, new plumbing, structural changes, roofing and full remodels. Rules vary by state.

  • Free for homeowners
  • No lead fees for pros
  • Rankings can't be bought

Quick answer

Start here

  • 1

    Small repairs and installs: handyman

  • 2

    Needs a permit: contractor

  • 3

    New wiring or plumbing: licensed trade

  • 4

    Check your state's rules

Plain-English, no jargon

Good jobs for a handyman

  • TV mounting, shelves and curtain rods
  • Drywall patches and touch-up painting
  • Furniture and equipment assembly
  • Replacing a light fixture or ceiling fan on existing wiring
  • Door adjustments, hardware and weatherstripping
  • Caulking, grout and small carpentry fixes

When you need a contractor or licensed trade

  • Running new electrical circuits or adding outlets
  • Moving or adding plumbing lines
  • Removing or changing walls
  • Roofing, foundations and structural repairs
  • Kitchen and bathroom remodels
  • Any job that needs a building permit

Why it matters

Unpermitted or unlicensed work can fail inspection when you sell, void insurance coverage or create safety hazards. Many states also cap the dollar value of jobs an unlicensed handyman can take on.

Questions to ask either one

  • Are you insured, and can I see the certificate?
  • Is this a flat price or hourly, and what's not included?
  • Will this job need a permit, and who pulls it?
  • How do you handle problems found once work starts?

FAQ

Common questions

Is a handyman cheaper than a contractor?

For small jobs, usually. Handymen often bill hourly or by task. Contractors price larger projects and manage permits, crews and inspections.

Can a handyman do electrical work?

Simple swaps on existing wiring are often allowed. New circuits and panel work generally require a licensed electrician. Check your state's rules.

Does a handyman need a license?

It depends on the state. Some require a license above a certain job value, and some don't license handymen at all. Insurance is worth asking for either way.

Need a pro for this?

Tell us about the job once. We match you with up to three local pros. No account, no fee, and your request is never resold.

Get free quotes
Handyman vs. Contractor: Which Do You Need? | Job Hound